This being President's Day I got to thinking about our presidents and how they rank. There have been numerous surveys and polls by historians and non-historians over the years.
Lincoln is universally favored as our best. Because he 1)saved us from the civil war, 2) freed the slaves and 3) was assassinated. Of course it does not matter if #1 and 2 are not entirely true, they have been added to our cultural folklore of old honest Abe.
FDR saved us from the depression and WWII. So he rules too.
JFK was good-looking, screwed Marilyn and was also assassinated.
Reagan is beloved for "saving us from the Russkies" and engenders fierce man crushes from Republicans. Others come and go with the times, like the resurgence of Truman or decline of Eisenhower in the eyes of history.
In my opinion the best presidents were
1. Lincoln
2. Washington
3. FDR
4. TR
5. Jefferson
6. Monroe
7. Cleveland
8. Truman
9. Polk
10 Eisenhower
The worst were:
1. William Henry Harrison
2. Buchanan
3. Andrew Johnson
4. Harding
5. Pierce
There are flawed presidencies like LBJ, Nixon and Grant or even Clinton, where extremely capable men floundered their opportunity or let personal demons get the better of them.
George W. and truthfully Clinton still should appear in a list of "too soon to tell" along with Reagan as we need to wait a generation before pronouncing sentence on their terms. It may be safe to say now, however that G.W. Bush will go down as a more impactful (for bad or good) president than Clinton. Because of 9/11, terrorism and Iraq if for no other reason. Poor Clinton, who all his life wanted to be a great president simply didn't have the big events occur on his watch.